JavaScript and Cookies are required to view this site. Please enable both in your browser settings.
Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo
Documenting Reality True Crime & Artistic Endeavors True Crime, Cold Cases, & Death Investigations Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo

Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo

Current Rating:
Unlimited Views No Ads No Algorithms Lifetime Account

Documenting Reality

Community Forum · Est. 2006

Join Now
Tools ▾
  #1  
● 11-10-2026, 02:42 PM
chris's Avatar
chris
Online Online
★ ★ GENERAL ★ ★
Poster Rank:36
male
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 43,140
Contributions: 35
Joined Oct 2006·Rank #36
 
43,140Posts
102,912Thanked
21,413Quoted
2,301Mentioned
35Contrib.
Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo

Kristin Smart, a 19-year-old freshman at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, disappeared after an off-campus party on the night of May 24-25, 1996. Paul Flores, the fellow freshman last seen with her, was convicted of her murder more than 26 years later. Her body has never been found.

Smart grew up in Stockton, California, and graduated from Lincoln High School in 1995. She and Flores enrolled at Cal Poly that fall and lived in separate residence halls. In the weeks before her disappearance, friends noticed Flores following her and spending time in the common area of her dorm. Smart was uncomfortable with his attention and did not return his interest.

On May 24, Smart attended a party at a student's house on Crandall Way near campus. Flores was also there. By the time guests began leaving, Smart was lying semiconscious on the ground outside. Cheryl Anderson and Timothy Davis helped her up and started walking her back to campus. Flores joined them.

Davis left the group at his dorm, and Flores took over supporting Smart. Near Anderson's residence hall, Anderson made him promise to get Smart safely to her room. She then left them together. Flores later told investigators he accompanied Smart as far as his own dorm, Santa Lucia Hall, before she continued alone toward Muir Hall.

The next morning, Smart's roommate found her bed untouched and her personal belongings still in the room. Campus police initially suspected she had taken an unannounced trip. Flores was interviewed repeatedly in the days after her disappearance. He denied romantic interest in Smart and gave differing explanations for a black eye, including basketball and work on his truck.

In June 1996, four dogs trained to detect human remains alerted at Flores's dorm room and his bed. Investigators seized bedding, but no charges followed for decades. Smart was declared legally dead on May 25, 2002.

Chris Lambert began releasing the podcast "Your Own Backyard" in September 2019, reviving interest in the case and bringing forward new witnesses. Court-approved wiretaps and searches followed in 2020. In March 2021, investigators searched beneath the deck at the Arroyo Grande home of Flores's father, Ruben Flores. The prosecution's case included biological evidence in the soil as evidence that Smart's body had been buried there and later moved.

Paul and Ruben Flores were arrested on April 13, 2021. Paul was charged with first-degree murder committed during a rape or attempted rape. Ruben was charged as an accessory after the fact. Both maintained their innocence.

After a defense-requested change of venue, the men went on trial together in Monterey County before separate juries. Opening statements began July 18, 2022. The prosecution argued that Paul Flores killed Smart in his dorm room while attempting to rape her. His defense maintained that Smart was alive and able to walk when they parted, challenged the dog evidence and disputed the credibility of witnesses who came forward years later.

On Oct. 18, 2022, one jury convicted Paul Flores of first-degree murder. The other acquitted Ruben Flores. Judge Jennifer O'Keefe denied motions for a new trial and acquittal on March 10, 2023, and sentenced Paul Flores to 25 years to life.

The California Court of Appeal affirmed the conviction and sentence on Oct. 24, 2025. The California Supreme Court denied review on Jan. 11, 2026. Flores is held at California State Prison, Corcoran.

Investigators continued searching for Smart's remains. On May 6, 2026, the San Luis Obispo County Sheriff's Office served a search warrant at Susan Flores's home in Arroyo Grande, using ground-penetrating radar and collecting soil samples. The search ended May 10 without recovering Smart's remains.

This thread contains 31 case-file documents and reports, 30 photographs of people and places in the case, one video of a 1996 detective interview with Paul Flores, and 14 court documents.
paul-flores-convicted-14.jpg
110.7 KB ·7 views
paul-flores-convicted-15.jpg
562.2 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-16.jpg
169.0 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-17.jpg
123.9 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-18.jpg
52.9 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-19.jpg
22.8 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-20.jpg
89.4 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-21.jpg
212.3 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-22.jpg
188.4 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-23.jpg
293.0 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-24.jpg
292.2 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-25.jpg
238.8 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-26.jpg
271.8 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-27.jpg
219.9 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-28.jpg
458.0 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-29.jpg
311.1 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-30.jpg
198.1 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-31.jpg
477.2 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-32.jpg
257.1 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-33.jpg
253.5 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-34.jpg
337.2 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-35.jpg
379.5 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-36.jpg
258.4 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-37.jpg
296.4 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-38.jpg
45.3 KB ·3 views
paul-flores-convicted-39.jpg
46.3 KB ·3 views
paul-flores-convicted-40.jpg
18.4 KB ·3 views
paul-flores-convicted-41.jpg
34.0 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-42.jpg
2.57 MB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-43.jpg
241.4 KB ·2 views
paul-flores-convicted-44.jpg
160.3 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-45.jpg
227.4 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-46.jpg
41.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-47.jpg
38.8 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-48.jpg
238.8 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-49.jpg
116.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-50.jpg
233.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-51.jpg
174.9 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-52.jpg
39.3 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-53.jpg
167.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-54.jpg
40.4 KB ·1 views
Click here to remove ›
173.66 MB ·3 views DownloadMember
__________________
Support the site and our continued existence by upgrading to a Green Name
▼ PROMO FROM DOCUMENTING REALITY
No surprises here
Join Now
Hidden for upgraded members.
  #2  
● 11-10-2026, 02:42 PM
chris's Avatar
chris
Online Online
★ ★ GENERAL ★ ★
Poster Rank:36
male
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 43,140
Contributions: 35
Joined Oct 2006·Rank #36
 
43,140Posts
102,912Thanked
21,413Quoted
2,301Mentioned
35Contrib.
Re: Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo

Court filings, investigative reports and related records

These 12 documents include court records and investigative reports in the Kristin Smart case, a state police homicide file from Santa Fe and related documents.

Court filings and orders

Date and time Length Details
May 27 and 28, 2022; June 6, 2022 38 pages Prosecution opposition to dismissal, describing a witness-intimidation investigation
May 31, 2022; June 6, 2022 20 pages Defense motion to exclude cadaver dog testimony, with supporting legal arguments
June 14, 2022 576 pages Monterey County Superior Court minute orders from Paul Flores's jury selection
June 16, 2022 6 pages Defense list of over 100 witnesses potentially mentioned at trial

Investigative and forensic reports

Date and time Length Details
July 26, 1996; Oct. 19 and 25, 2021 36 pages Sheriff's interview reports concerning the weekend Kristin Smart disappeared
Nov. 19, 1998 5 pages Sheriff's supplemental report on tips about a possible link to Smart
June 19, 2011 2,806 pages New Mexico State Police homicide investigation index and transcribed 911 call
March 22, 2022 33 pages Sheriff's burial-expert interview report with attached forensic and laboratory records
June 18, 2022 3 pages Defense biologist's supplemental DNA report on mattress cover linked to Paul Flores

Immunity letter
  • District attorney's letter granting immunity for post-death conduct in exchange for cooperation
Blood test presentation
  • Slide presentation validating a hemoglobin test for identifying human blood
Missing person flyer
  • Reward flyer seeking information about Kristin Smart's disappearance and Paul Flores
paul-flores-convicted-67.jpg
210.6 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-68.jpg
203.5 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-69.jpg
195.4 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-70.jpg
43.1 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-71.jpg
232.9 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-72.jpg
108.8 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-73.jpg
189.4 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-74.jpg
267.9 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-75.jpg
242.4 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-76.jpg
39.3 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-77.jpg
175.3 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-78.jpg
292.1 KB ·1 views
__________________
Support the site and our continued existence by upgrading to a Green Name
  #3  
● 11-10-2026, 02:42 PM
chris's Avatar
chris
Online Online
★ ★ GENERAL ★ ★
Poster Rank:36
male
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 43,140
Contributions: 35
Joined Oct 2006·Rank #36
 
43,140Posts
102,912Thanked
21,413Quoted
2,301Mentioned
35Contrib.
Re: Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo

Police records, warrants and trial documents

These 12 documents include police reports, warrant affidavits and records from Paul Flores's trial and post-conviction proceedings.

Police reports

Date and time Length Details
March 12, 1996 2 pages Sheriff's telephone interview report concerning Smart, her acquaintances and shoes
June 25, 1996 4 pages Cal Poly police supplemental report and activity log covering June interviews

Warrants and affidavits

Date and time Length Details
June 20, 2000 22 pages Search affidavit seeking Smart's remains and belongings at Arroyo Grande property
April 6, 2021 16 pages Probable cause arrest warrant and affidavit against Paul Ruben Flores

Trial transcripts

Date and time Length Details
July 18, 2022 92 pages Opening statements, including objections to PowerPoint presentations
Oct. 4, 2022 115 pages Defense closing argument and a juror question about testimony

Court filings

Date and time Length Details
June 6, 2022 16 pages Prosecution memorandum identifying defendants' statements intended for use at trial
July 11, 2022 14 pages Susan Flores's motion to quash trial subpoena on Fifth Amendment grounds
March 3, 2023 2 pages Prosecution opposition to Paul Flores's motion for judgment of acquittal
March 10, 2023 50 pages Defense new-trial motion challenging prosecution conduct, scientific evidence and testimony
Date not given 11 pages Prosecution motion to exclude defense questions about third-party culpability
paul-flores-convicted-91.jpg
263.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-92.jpg
231.4 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-93.jpg
241.1 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-94.jpg
167.1 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-95.jpg
116.8 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-96.jpg
116.4 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-97.jpg
179.1 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-98.jpg
214.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-99.jpg
158.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-100.jpg
186.8 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-101.jpg
255.3 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-102.jpg
178.5 KB ·1 views
__________________
Support the site and our continued existence by upgrading to a Green Name
  #4  
● 11-10-2026, 02:42 PM
chris's Avatar
chris
Online Online
★ ★ GENERAL ★ ★
Poster Rank:36
male
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 43,140
Contributions: 35
Joined Oct 2006·Rank #36
 
43,140Posts
102,912Thanked
21,413Quoted
2,301Mentioned
35Contrib.
Re: Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo

Trial motions and appeal records

These nine court documents cover evidentiary motions, a dismissal request and post-conviction proceedings, including the opinion affirming Paul Flores's murder conviction.

Court filings

Date and time Length Details
May 31, 2022 24 pages Defense dismissal motion alleging outrageous government conduct, with counsel declaration
June 6, 2022 22 pages Prosecution motion to admit evidence of Paul Flores's prior sexual offenses
June 6, 2022 13 pages Prosecution motion to admit cadaver dog handler testimony
July 14, 2022 38 pages Media coalition motion to unseal records and permit remote access
March 3, 2023 177 pages Prosecution opposition to new trial, disputing misconduct and judicial error
Oct. 21, 2024 105 pages Paul Flores's opening appeal brief challenging juror bias and evidentiary rulings
April 14, 2025 109 pages Attorney general's response addressing evidence, juror issues and uncharged rapes
July 7, 2025 75 pages Paul Flores's reply brief challenging juror bias, evidence and jury instructions

Appellate court opinion
  • Court of Appeal opinion affirming Paul Flores's murder conviction
paul-flores-convicted-112.jpg
237.1 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-113.jpg
186.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-114.jpg
200.2 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-115.jpg
191.1 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-116.jpg
151.8 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-117.jpg
154.9 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-118.jpg
171.4 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-119.jpg
144.1 KB ·1 views
paul-flores-convicted-120.jpg
153.7 KB ·1 views
__________________
Support the site and our continued existence by upgrading to a Green Name
Documenting Reality True Crime & Artistic Endeavors True Crime, Cold Cases, & Death Investigations Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo
Documenting Reality True Crime & Artistic Endeavors True Crime, Cold Cases, & Death Investigations Paul Flores Convicted of Kristin Smart's Murder in San Luis Obispo


Powered by vBulletin Copyright 2000-2010 Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO