[Faustus]

I work practically around the block from the house in a town called Massapequa. I've got a friend who's father used to drink with DeFeo at the local bar on Rte 110.

It's so weird to drive by the house, because it's actually facing the side of the street. I guess there was a lot more land back in the day.

But yea, legendary case.

[christmascandy1]

is that pic supposed to be a (fake) 2??...cause most (blue) eyed ppl get pics like this..i know a ton in my family do..( alot of blue eyes)...im just wondering...?

[Adam76]

Picture #4 , is kinda spooky. The boy, shining eyes.....spooky.

[Black Knight]

Originally Posted by ELEEOZ ↗

I was born in Amityville, now live near the border. Amity Harbor is absolutely beautiful.
DeFeo killed his family for the insurance money, he was freebasing cocaine. I have read he did drug his family that night that is why noone woke up.....does not account for the entire street though. The neighbors next door, were REAL close. Like houses in the city...built right on top of each other.
The Lutz's bought that house for peanuts. They claim it was haunted, and never went back, yet had a garage sale after they put it up for sale.
The house is beautiful, but they changed the windows of course.
Many houses around it look exactly the same, and right across the street they kept their "eye" windows.
De Feo Sr. was a pig that beat his family, but still, Jr. should not have taken them all out.

thanks for the info about the yard sale. That right there sealed the "validity" of their claims right there.

[Cyn]

The pic of the boy was taken by psychic medium, Dianne Warren when she toured the house while the Lutz family lived there. This is the original. Dianne had been on a few episodes recently of Paranormal State.

[R33f3r]

Didn't the father own Islip Speedway at one time? My dad worked at South Shore Toyota right down the road from the house back in the day. It was a regular topic of conversation at the garage.

[DeeMarieGK]

Originally Posted by R33f3r ↗

Didn't the father own Islip Speedway at one time? My dad worked at South Shore Toyota right down the road from the house back in the day. It was a regular topic of conversation at the garage.

I do believe the man who moved into the home after The Lutzes "ran out."
South Shore Toyota on Sunrise? It is now called Atlantic Toyota.

[R33f3r]

Originally Posted by ELEEOZ ↗

I do believe the man who moved into the home after The Lutzes "ran out."
South Shore Toyota on Sunrise? It is now called Atlantic Toyota.

Yup right there on the corner, he worked there for many years before we moved to New England.

[DeeMarieGK]

I completely skipped over the reason for my first comment!
The Islip Speedway was owned by the man who moved in after the Lutz's. Duh me

[lonnewulf]

Dear Lord this is so fucking screwed up. I hate my Dad for always siding with my bitchass sister, but it has never come to me to murder my whole family...