#1
|
Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a Highway Father, daughter killed because woman stopped car to help ducks, prosecutor alleges MONTREAL - A woman who stopped to help a group of ducklings on the side of the road shed tears Friday as she was found guilty of causing the deaths of a motorcyclist and his passenger daughter who slammed into her parked car. The lawyer for Emma Czornobaj said his client was in shock after she was convicted by a jury on two counts of criminal negligence causing death and two counts of dangerous driving causing death. Czornobaj, 25, was charged in the deaths of Andre Roy, 50, and his daughter Jessie, 16, on a Montreal-area highway. She wiped away tears when the verdict was delivered to a packed courtroom in Montreal. Quebec Superior Court Justice Eliane Perreault asked each of the 10 men and two women on the jury member whether they agreed with the verdict and they replied unanimously in favour. The jury reached its decision as it entered its fourth day of deliberations on Friday. Czornobaj was released until her pre-sentence hearing on Aug. 8. She did not say anything to reporters and walked quickly by them in the courthouse corridor with her mother, holding up a newspaper to hide her face. Criminal negligence causing death carries a maximum life sentence while the charge of dangerous driving causing death comes with a maximum of 14 years in jail. Czornobaj has no previous criminal record. Pauline Volikakis, whose husband and daughter were killed in the collision, briefly fought back tears when she left the courtroom. She refused to speculate about a possible sentence, saying she just wanted to get on with her life. "It's been difficult," said Volikakis. "But it's finished. We're moving on other things (and) we hope it will go well. "I don't wish misfortune on anyone," she added. "It's time that we go on. This will not bring (back) my loved ones." Volikakis was driving another motorcycle behind her husband when the collision happened. She was driving more slowly and managed to avoid injury. A provincial police officer testified at the trial that Roy, whose speed was estimated at 113 km/h and 129 km/h when he applied his brakes, collided with Czornobaj's car at between 105 km/h and 121 km/h. Roy's motorcycle slammed into Czornobaj's car, which was stopped in the left lane of a provincial highway in Candiac, south of Montreal. His daughter was riding on the back of the motorcycle when the collision happened on June 27, 2010. The trial heard that Czornobaj, who had three years' driving experience at the time, had stopped to rescue ducklings on the side of the road. The professed animal lover told the court that she did not see the ducklings' mother anywhere and planned to capture them and take them home. Defence lawyer Marc Labelle said his client was stunned by the jury's decision. "The fact that she was involved in the accident in the first place was a hard experience for her," he said. "The fact that she had to go through a trial with a lot of publicity was tough and to be confirmed by 12 citizens, the jury, that the conduct was criminal is a hard blow." Labelle, who has been a lawyer for around 30 years, pointed out that the case was a unique one. "It's the first time I do a trial where it is obvious that there is no criminal intent," he said. Outside the courtroom, Crown prosecutor Annie-Claude Chasse publicly thanked the jury for their work. "We do have a lot of respect for all the work of the jury," Chasse said. "They did not have any easy questions to answer." The Crown attorney also had a message for motorists. "What we hope is that a clear message is sent to society that we do not stop on the highway for animals. It's not worth it." |
The Following 8 Users Say Thank You to Illusion For This Useful Post: | ||
gatagato, jesse, K9Grip, Kanda444, kellyhound, Megamel29, Pollucy, Xfactor |
#2
|
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High sad story... but she really should have known better than to park in the road to save some ducks. her empathy for the ducks caused a dangerous situation which resulted in the deaths of people. horrible mistake to make.... |
The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Kanda444 For This Useful Post: | ||
CrunchyCripple, FunkPumpkin, gatagato, Paupercool1, rapeWhistle, winvens |
#3
|
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High Sad story all around. ![]() |
The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to bob351 For This Useful Post: | ||
Kanda444, kellyhound, Kelseecat65, Paupercool1, winvens |
#4
| |
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High Quote:
Rear-end collisions are ALWAYS the fault of the motorist who rear-ends the vehicle in front of them. This woman's conviction needs to be overturned on appeal. The motorcyclist's negligence is what caused his own deatg and the death of his daughter. |
The Following 11 Users Say Thank You to OhJstFkOffAlrdy For This Useful Post: | ||
260RS, 30564U, alyjo07, CrunchyCripple, Darkest Angel, jesse, jinhwangtikatang, Kelseecat65, Megamel29, Schmuck, Shadedwill |
The Following 3 Users Said Fuck Off to OhJstFkOffAlrdy For This Post: | ||
CrazyDiamond,
Illusion,
rapeWhistle |
#5
| |||
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High Quote:
as an example, california law says: Quote:
Quote:
![]() it's such a dangerous issue, in Washington and Oregon, you can get a fine for not being in the far lane when passing a cop that is pulling somebody over. Even with flashing lights, it's dangerous to stop in the middle of a freeway for any reason, especially to save some ducks. also, keep in mind... if you were driving and another motorist were to cut you off, then slam on their brakes leaving you no time to stop... you are saying that you should be at fault for that? if that happens to you, i'd keep that bit of info to yourself... because it's not your fault in that case, that is, until you admit fault. |
The Following 7 Users Say Thank You to Kanda444 For This Useful Post: | ||
30564U, gatagato, Illusion, Paupercool1, pyromancer555, rapeWhistle, winvens |
#6
| |
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High Quote:
Ontario - Highway Traffic Act No person shall stop a vehicle in such manner as to impede or render dangerous the use of the highway by others, except in the case of an emergency, an accident, or a mechanical breakdown. In the event of such an emergency, accident, or breakdown, the emergency flashing lights of such vehicle shall be turned on if the vehicle is equipped with such lights and such lights are in working order. If the driver is capable of safely doing so and the vehicle is movable, the driver may move the vehicle from the roadway to prevent obstructing the regular flow of traffic; provided, however, that the movement of the vehicle to prevent the obstruction of traffic shall not relieve the law-enforcement officer of his duty pursuant to § 46.2-373. A report of the vehicle's location shall be made to the nearest law-enforcement officer as soon as practicable, and the vehicle shall be moved from the roadway to the shoulder as soon as possible and removed from the shoulder without unnecessary delay. If the vehicle is not promptly removed, such removal may be ordered by a law-enforcement officer at the expense of the owner if the disabled vehicle creates a traffic hazard. Signal for stop (8) The driver or operator of a vehicle upon a highway before stopping or suddenly decreasing the speed of the vehicle, if the operation of any other vehicle may be affected by such stopping or decreasing of speed, shall give a signal plainly visible to the driver or operator of the other vehicle of the intention to stop or decrease speed. |
The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Illusion For This Useful Post: | ||
30564U, gatagato, Kanda444, Paupercool1, pyromancer555, winvens |
#7
| ||||||||
My Rank: FIRST SERGEANT Poster Rank:388 Female Join Date: May 2013 Mentioned: 13 Post(s) Quoted: 1088 Post(s)
| ||||||||
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High So, did he hit her when she suddenly stopped? Or was she already stopped and he came upon the car and hit it? The first one is understandable - the second one would just be the dead guy not paying attention. Either way, this woman is an idiot for parking in the road. |
The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to CrunchyCripple For This Useful Post: | ||
30564U, Kelseecat65, Paupercool1, winvens |
#8
|
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High There are simply no 'winners' in this case. Tragic all around. |
The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Soar For This Useful Post: | ||
Darkest Angel, Illusion, Kelseecat65, Paupercool1, rapeWhistle, winvens |
#9
|
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High Did anyone not notice that the person on the other bike avoided the accident because they were traveling at a slower rate of speed? That alone tells me that this guy was traveling faster than he was able to react. And Kanda, I've had people jump in front of me and slam on their brakes. Every single time, I avoided collision by being cautious and attentive. I've also avoided collisions with people who were stopped or travelling well below the minimum highway speed, because I never traveled faster than my reaction time. You can cite all the ordnances you want, but inattention is inattention. Traffic laws are designed so that the responding officers can cite pretty much anyone involved for pretty much anything. The fact still remains that if the guy on the motorcycle had been a better rider, he and his daughter would still be alive. |
The Following 4 Users Say Thank You to OhJstFkOffAlrdy For This Useful Post: | ||
alyjo07, CrunchyCripple, jesse, Megamel29 |
#10
| ||
Re: Quebec Woman Sentenced to Jail After Helping a Family of Ducks Cross a High Quote:
You were not at the crime scene. Everything you just stated was your opinion. You can argue all you want that the deaths were the result of an unfortunate accident but the fact remains that when this lady stopped her vehicle on a busy highway she had reckless disregard for the safety of others and is undoubtedly criminal behaviour. Quote:
|
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to Illusion For This Useful Post: | ||
Paupercool1, rapeWhistle |