|
#1
●
11-21-2026, 06:52 PM
|
|
911 Call About The Death of Nancy Pfister at Her Aspen Home
Nancy Pfister, 57, an Aspen socialite whose family helped develop the Buttermilk ski area, was found dead in a locked bedroom closet at her Buttermilk Mountain home on Feb. 26, 2014. Her tenant, retired Denver anesthesiologist William "Trey" Styler III, later confessed to killing her after a dispute over rent and repairs. Pfister was the daughter of Art Pfister, a Buttermilk co-founder. She grew up in Basalt, worked as a tour guide and raised two children as a single mother in a log home her father built in 1991. Styler and his wife, Nancy Styler, moved into the house on Sept. 24, 2013, as Pfister prepared to travel to Australia. Illness had forced Styler to close his medical practice, leaving the couple in debt. They planned to open a spa in Aspen. The rental arrangement deteriorated over broken appliances and unpaid rent. The Stylers withheld the $4,000 rent until repairs were made. Kathy Carpenter, Pfister's friend and assistant, acted as an intermediary, arranging repairs and receiving $6,000 in cash from the couple. The Stylers agreed to leave by Feb. 22, 2014, and moved to a Basalt motel. Pfister cut her trip short and returned that day, but their belongings remained in the house. She allowed them to return to collect their possessions and began locking the house during the day when they were slow to finish. Investigators placed the killing on the morning of Feb. 24. Pfister was attacked in bed with a hammer and an ax. Her body was wrapped in plastic bags and blankets, bound with an extension cord and placed in the master bedroom closet. The mattress was flipped to conceal a bloodstain. A medical examination found that she died from blunt force trauma to the head and blood loss. Two days later, Carpenter went to the house after Pfister missed work and did not answer her calls. She unlocked the closet with a key, found the body and called 911. A Basalt city worker found a bag in a public trash bin behind the Stylers' motel containing a bloody hammer, a pill bottle bearing Pfister's name and the registration card for the couple's Jaguar. A closet key was later found near another trash can outside the motel. The Stylers were arrested on March 3. Carpenter was arrested about three weeks after the killing. All three faced first-degree murder charges. Before a preliminary hearing, Trey Styler confessed and said he had acted alone. He described leaving the motel while his wife slept, driving to Pfister's home and attacking her. He said he had snapped over Pfister's treatment of his wife. On June 20, 2014, Styler, then 66, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and received a 20-year prison sentence. Charges against both women were dropped. The plea agreement barred future charges against Nancy Styler in the killing; charges against Carpenter could be refiled if new evidence emerged. Styler was found hanged in his cell at Arrowhead Correctional Facility in Fremont County on Aug. 6, 2015. He was 67. ·
__________________ Support the site and our continued existence by upgrading to a Green Name |