JavaScript and Cookies are required to view this site. Please enable both in your browser settings.
Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Current Rating:
Unlimited Views No Ads No Algorithms Lifetime Account

Documenting Reality

Community Forum · Est. 2006

Join Now
Tools ▾
  #1  
● 06-28-2009, 09:05 PM
Ketaset's Avatar
Ketaset
Offline: Offline
My Rank: PRIVATE
Poster Rank:11539
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 10
Joined Jun 2009·Rank #11,539
 
10Posts
20Thanked
0Quoted
0Mentioned
0Contrib.
Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

I didn't see it here, so I'll post it, courtesy of a site with simply awesome information on the guillotine and a pictorial history.
Scroll down to the bottom of this page for the clip.


History of the Guillotine




A new incredible filmed document has surfaced in the last 5 years, documenting the guillotine execution of two men. The people who made the film public have asserted that it is the 1933 execution of Veteau and Martin, by Anatole Deibler, in the city of Angouleme. The film is of poor quality but an incredible document from a historical standpoint. As I viewed it, I came to the immediate realization that it could not be the execution it claims to be. The first issue is the type of the equipment used. The jerky pictures, grainy quality, wildly varying speed and exposure from frame to frame points to a hand-cranked camera of pre-1920 vintage not what would typically be used in 1933. The opening scene, pictured on the right, shows the guillotine in a brightly lit dirt venue in front of a prison gate. Deibler carefully notes in his "carnet" that Veteau and Martin were executed at 3:50AM on July 20th, in total darkness. The architecture of the prison, with the vertical slit wall openings, the arched gateway and the characteristic base stonework is near identical to the modern shot of the "Maison Centrale" in Tonkin (Hanoi) shown below. The first letter of the word "MAISON" can be discerned over the door inside the red circle. Click here for an older photo. The "Maison Centrale" later became known to captured US aviators as the "Hanoi Hilton". Other issues such as the clothing worn by the spectators and the unpaved city street do point to a colonial setting rather than to a 1933 French provincial town. The guillotine is definitely a real model 1872 Berger and there is little doubt about the authenticity of the footage itself. The following scene takes place right after the opening general scene above, before either of the two executions has been filmed. The camera has been moved closer and becomes completely stationary for the remainder of the sequence. This camera is obviously on a fixed tripod and not handheld by an amateur standing in the middle of a crowd of onlookers. There are no people between the movie camera and the guillotine. Considering the outrage caused by the filming of the Weidmann execution in 1939 (Done secretly from an apartment window) it is impossible to imagine how a professional cinematographer could have been allowed to set up a fixed camera, practically overhanging the zinc tub, in France in 1933... This is the kind of thing that could only happen in a colonial setting far away from the eyes of the French government. The scene shows an aide leaning into the basket and also the blade in the dropped position. In the red circle we can clearly see that the blade is bloody, which is inconsistent with the fact that this scene precedes the first of the "two" executions. Immediately following this scene a bucket of water is thrown on the bascule and blade, obviously to wash off the blood of the first victim (before the "first" execution). Noteworthy also are the facts that the ropes are not "stored" on the hooks as they would normally be but instead are draped over the back of the bucket and also that there is no shield around the tub (Possibly an arrangement between the photographer and the executioner?). Such "sloppiness" is not likely from Deibler's well-trained team of professionals. After this, the first condemned man is brought forward and as he is "tilted" on the bascule one of the aides whips open the basket and reveals what we already suspected, the foot of a corpse in the basket (in the red circle). This is the final confirmation that we are dealing with a triple, not a double execution. Other notable facts are that the condemned men wear no shoes and that the executioner's aides wear loose fitting canvas uniforms similar to what was worn at the Bagne in Guyana. My best guess is that the film clip is from 1915 to 1920 and shows a triple execution of "forcats" at the Maison Centrale in Tonkin, Northern province of French Indochina.
Click here to remove ›
3.48 MB ·32136 views DownloadMember
▲ 14 Users Say Thank You For This Post:
Brainplague, condor5, Fulcanelli, masoud_f_3t, Oswald2001, Overgrued, Painedexistence, Paupercool1, TargetX, tecumseh35, TheBunnyOverlord, Tools., vi36196, William May
▼ PROMO FROM DOCUMENTING REALITY
Cheaper than the doctor bills, guaranteed
Join Now
Hidden for upgraded members.
  #2  
● 06-29-2009, 04:06 AM
güttsfükk's Avatar
güttsfükk
Offline: Offline
Super *********
Poster Rank:90
Join Date: Nov 2008
Posts: 17,370
Joined Nov 2008·Rank #90
 
17,370Posts
13,739Thanked
99Quoted
5Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

that's a very cool post, it goes well in hand with http://www.documentingreality.com/fo...ecution-13634/
▲ This User Says Thank You For This Post:
TheBunnyOverlord
  #3  
● 07-18-2009, 09:49 AM
DarwinsMistake's Avatar
DarwinsMistake
Offline: Offline
┌∩┐(◣_◢)┌∩
Poster Rank:31
Pointing true north
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 48,500
Joined Jul 2009·Rank #31
 
48,500Posts
21,702Thanked
2,806Quoted
13Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Rare and awesome find guys thanks Keteset !
▲ 2 Users Say Thank You For This Post:
Oswald2001, TheBunnyOverlord
  #4  
● 10-07-2009, 06:18 PM
annmarie's Avatar
annmarie
Offline: Offline
My Rank: FIRST SERGEANT
Poster Rank:396
Black sexy female doctor
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 3,069
Joined Aug 2009·Rank #396
 
3,069Posts
242Thanked
9Quoted
1Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

love the vid
▲ This User Says Thank You For This Post:
TheBunnyOverlord
  #5  
● 10-07-2009, 06:55 PM
z0death's Avatar
z0death
Offline: Offline
My Rank: MASTER SERGEANT
Poster Rank:542
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,880
Joined Sep 2009·Rank #542
 
1,880Posts
661Thanked
7Quoted
0Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Bloody hell... that's better quality than half the beheading vids!

Great vid
▲ This User Says Thank You For This Post:
TheBunnyOverlord
  #6  
● 11-03-2010, 09:07 PM
Graphcorp
Offline: Offline
★ Legacy Member ★
Poster Rank:27088
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 1
Joined Dec 2009·Rank #27,088
 
1Posts
0Thanked
0Quoted
0Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Has anybody noticed that the "DIVX" logo in the lower left-hand corner is backwards? It might give us a better perspective if the film was flipped...
  #7  
● 11-04-2010, 11:23 PM
St. Geno's Avatar
St. Geno
Offline: Offline
I don't fuck with anyone
Poster Rank:117
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 13,759
Joined Feb 2010·Rank #117
 
13,759Posts
13,014Thanked
2,253Quoted
19Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

cool
  #8  
● 11-05-2010, 10:10 AM
ChockFullOfChock's Avatar
ChockFullOfChock
Offline: Offline
Madonna vergine bugiarda.
Poster Rank:443
Male
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 2,608
Joined May 2010·Rank #443
 
2,608Posts
1,385Thanked
11Quoted
0Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Thanks for the bump. Good vid.
  #9  
● 11-18-2010, 06:18 PM
petedeamon's Avatar
petedeamon
Offline: Offline
My Rank: MASTER SERGEANT
Poster Rank:530
yes
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,946
Joined Sep 2009·Rank #530
 
1,946Posts
1,022Thanked
93Quoted
0Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Great post!!!
  #10  
● 11-19-2010, 12:31 PM
aaargh
Offline: Offline
So Fucking Banned
Poster Rank:67
Dragon
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 23,884
Joined Sep 2009·Rank #67
 
23,884Posts
12,489Thanked
12,161Quoted
114Mentioned
0Contrib.
Re: Triple Guillotine Execution in Tonkin (Hanoi) 1915

Really bothers me how they situate their own heads in, like they are at the barber.

Jesus, lash out! Scream or cry or something! It really bothers me how they lay their own heads down.


Powered by vBulletin Copyright 2000-2010 Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO